[article] Death to the self-playing game

Hello! I want to try and engage in more long-form critical game design discussions here; this is my first effort in starting that. Sharing a game-design article and some of the thoughts I have about it.

The article being paywalled, I will base this topic off of the freely accessible section.

This is something I feel very strongly about. This article is about the almost self-playing games, some that I have near no respect for (Ball X Pitt is offensively poorly designed), the survivors genre specifically is one thing I wish never happened. But there is nuances to this, and I want to argue about them for a bit. Following paragraphs are fragmented thoughts, they are not connected to each other necessarily.


I have no gripe with mechanically-focused games being somewhat guiding in the way you play — for I do believe that forcing the hand of someone to do something using available game mechanics is a way to make the player experience something specific; see Celeste’s or Super Meat Boy’s level design for example. The issue starts to arise for me in that type of game when the level design is set in a way where you have no way to play but to follow exactly the pattern set by the creator, and that pattern being uncreative. This is an issue with so many platformers and puzzlers I play that I won’t even try to name them.


One thing I despise heavily about games focused on meta progression; think most roguelites and MMORPGs; is the way they tend to trivialize the middle- to micro- gameplay loop and make it a chore to complete for the macro-loop. This is often done in a very intensively anti-player way, rewarding play-time rather than any form of personal achievement, and removing agency from the player (with very few exceptions, you can’t affect the pace of the macro-loop meaningfully in these games.) Those games don’t self-play per se, but they might as well with no change to the experience except removal of low-level play and grind.


Some near-self-playing games rely on meta-commentary to convey a message. This is, in my eyes, a pretty cheap and self-reflecting way to commentate on the issue. You see it once, you’ve seen it all. Recent popular example of this might be Unfair Flip, a pretty uninteresting and self-justifying game.


Most of the crap that comes out in the form of reducing gameplay complexity seems to correlates to a decrease in involvement from the players in the long term. Gameplay literacy is getting worse, and many will play crap if it occupies their hands and troubled minds. Great gameplay, with high standards for quality, is simply not a thing for most games, in the same way most young book readers don’t have standards for quality prose — notice the irony of me redacting this in my second language, resulting in poor prose.

It’s interesting to see this take from an established games writer. The entire games press seems to view a twin-stick shooter with no fire button as a revolutionary idea, and that vexes me. I also don’t understand the appeal of idle or clicker or even “auto-chess” games at all.

That said, I try not to just put down what other people enjoy, and obviously a lot of people enjoy these games. The problem is that the glut of them is making it harder for me to find what I enjoy. I was just looking for new (Wizardry-like) dungeon crawlers the other day, and most of what I found were idle clickers, Survivor-likes, and deckbuilders*. Discoverability is usually billed as a problem for developers, but it’s also a problem for players. Water, water, everywhere, nor any drop to drink.

Because of the paywall, I’m not sure what his conclusion is, but he argues that these types of games are accelerating a design trend away from genuine engagement and towards base psychological exploitation. I’m not sure where I stand on that. I somewhat hesitate to attribute that level of cynicism to a surprise hit indie game, since AAA and f2p games have been pushing that vector for decades. f2p in particular has it down to a science; they know exactly what mental buttons to push and how hard to push them in order to extract the maximum revenue from the player base.

If we grant the article’s assertion that self-playing games are largely dopamine dispensers, I could see the argument that this existing industry-wide trend has created a vicious cycle of supply and demand, and that self-playing games fit into and propagate that. I’m not sure, though, because it’s ultimately just one segment of the market. I see the industry as having been in decline for 25 years, so this particular (largely indie-driven, as far as I can tell) trend seems like a blip.

* It’s kind of funny that card game videogames were also a bit of a fad when M:tG was in its heyday, and now they are again, because of Slay the Spire and Balatro.

the perfect version of this, in my head is something ive been calling an execution puzzle, though i think sylvie games do this more clearly than anything else. in the game you know you have a certain set of tools (dash, double jump, mermaid jump etc.) and what these games are best at is simply leaving you with the idea that these tools are combined in some order, but its not always laid out other than through trial and error, or certain known-useful patterns you may have learned from the game already. and in these terms a hand-holding level is a puzzle with a trivial solution

what a self-playing game seems to be infatuated with is giving you a glut of these tools, offering them as choices, but then remaining totally un-curious about what they are used for or what your choices end up being.

I actually do think it is possible to critique from within the same genre, but what seems to plague really earnest attempts to do that is that its hard to do so without making some sort of “worst version” of that genre. So when a player goes ‘ugh, why am i even playing this’ it still tends to be read as a failure of design even when that may be the message the game wants to convey. i think this is more to do with what you say about ‘gameplay literacy’ though, or at least the things players presuppose about a game before starting it

I don’t think I can fully label it cynical either. If you are an indie developer (or aspiring) and happened to spend 60+ hours playing autochess games during the pandemic, it seems pretty natural at some point you’d come up with ideas for improvements or your own spins on them. thats more or less how anyone gets into gamedev in the first place? i think there are very few who have genuine ulterior motives about this, and the gravitation towards this type of game i think has been mostly natural and the results of feeling like there is a loss of opportunity around other types of games. i also feel the later on that you began getting involved in the field, the more likely you were surrounded by developers in a ‘survival’ mode and may not be getting the best lessons from them

The dangerous thinking in this is that we still broadly assume that indie games are at the heart of the solution to big issues in the games industry. During discussions like these it often feels like we are dealing with the sense of why an indie might feel more freedom to make something ‘cynical’ than a bigger studio. And I don’t think we can safely say that there is any inherently better quality of intention behind indie games - that is still effort and introspection you have to perform, and most do to some degree, but if that work is being excused for the base assumption that indie games are ‘better’ thats where it opens up to cynicism

There is definitely a segment of the indie scene that produces cynical work, because making a game that gets attention and sales is not necessarily the same thing as making a good game. This might be even more true with indie games than it is with AAA.

So I’ve now ran into the bsky post for this in the wild and now the discourse from that is infecting my brain, so i must infect the thread too. I didn’t realize this was being hotly-argued-over, hahaha

It feels like a lot of the reaction to this article has been challenging the idea that vampire survivors is a ‘self playing game’ in the first place, which i actually took totally as granted when reading the article. I think in my head this game is designed around at least some amount of ‘auto’ and dissecting to what degree it is automatic really doesn’t matter - it’s still part of the design goals. I guess my first question to the group is how much do you agree with the premise that the games do play themselves - and, does this really even matter to their argument?

What interests me is that the defense of it seems to be taking things quite personally or are super defensive of the idea that there is gameplay. Something speaks to me on how this might relate to gaming as an identity? I’ve always taken defenders of this game to have a pretty big ‘please dont take this away from me’ mindset even when they can see the parts of it that are manipulative or hostile.

its pretty tough because this is 100% a wall that will have to be dealt with more broadly to make any progress. how do we tackle these things without it feeling like an attack on how someone chooses to spend their time?

to answer my own question a little further, i don’t think that the game having elements that are automated or playing themselves strictly excludes the player from also being a participant in play. i suppose its two-player in that sense

This would be a lot easier if the full article was available. I feel kind of ignorant commenting on half an article, but jank.cool decided to make half an article available to the public, so they’re inviting it.

I haven’t played Vampire Survivors, but I think that it not being a purely idle game is part of the point. The article isn’t really about completely hands-off play, or else it would be about Progress Quest or something. The argument is that VS is an example of a wildly successful game that erodes and flattens the direct interaction of its parent genre (twin-stick shooters) into something more automated and less demanding (because while aiming and firing are central “verbs,” the game just does them for you). It then argues (I think) that this is a slippery slope towards an industry-wide decline in interactivity, and that this is solely destructive to some genres of games.

I think the key quote is “self-playing games take microdecisions away from you in favour of macrodecisions.”

If you just mean how we can critique entertainment media without some fans taking it personally, we probably can’t. I do think this specific article kind of edges on attacking players’ motivations or mental state. It doesn’t quite, but it could have been a bit less dramatic. Especially that last paragraph.

Sorry to necro, but I wrote a review of Ball X Pit a long time ago regarding auto-play elements over on Backloggd, if you are interested in more thoughts.

https://backloggd.com/u/vehemently/review/3592820/

I do agree that there is an element of fingerwagging that I’m not interested in. The simple or easy gameplay being bad is pretty easily dismissed. However, I do also think it’s worth talking about how certain design patterns have an overall negative effect on the player or the world at large, even if they are in the moment enjoyable. In the case of games like this, I think there’s an element of pointlessness and mindlessness that feels bad.

this is something that applies to both survivors and roguelikes in general - but the way these games are centered around your character build (one of the things defenders of them point towards since it is skill based) has started to be a sticking point to me.

For example, seeing different upgrade effects combine together can have fun and unpredictable results. There are certain builds that you can get in these games that will make you super powerful, or chain a bunch of effects in a row in a satisfying way, etc. The way you gain these upgrades is always pretty random though, so it feels like the value presented by the game is actually based in discontent. If I come up with the idea for a build i’d like to try, i might not get the upgrades i am looking for on my very next run, or i get the ‘central’ upgrade required for the build too late and have to take a lot of filler ones, etc. so… you start another run hoping that next one will get you the things you want

So overall you have mechanics that are fun, but as a designer to make them desirable you have to manufacture this frustration around them as a means of driving engagement. it just strikes me this is one of the cases where ‘good design’ and ‘fun’ don’t actually align with these games, and that they actually rely on a certain amount of discontent. it just feels incongruent to me

my official stance is you should definitely necro threads. Posting comes above all else

I’d rather people play a lottery-like video game than the actual lottery, for what it’s worth. It seems like something people want to do whether or not it’s good for them, and a video game is a pretty tame (relatively harmless?) way to engage with that feeling. I agree that it feels icky to think of game designers intentionally trying to exploit that urge, but I often wonder where one draws the line between “people find this fun so I’m putting it in my game” VS “people find this addicting so I put it in my game”. It seems like there’s a real grey area between the two.

I can understand this argument but I just can’t buy it, because I simply don’t believe that is ever the actual intent of a game even if it can be true sometimes for individuals. i was able to google a few studies that look into the effectiveness of games in addiction recovery but it seems like an individualized coping strategy at best

I think if a game came out actively with a survivor-like on the platform of being ‘harm reduction’ that sentiment would not be received well? I think it would be pretty controversial, even

edit: also! what is inherent to this type of game that would make it better or more effective for this purpose of recovery/reduction than other games? they do have more addictive qualities to them than say a platformer, so on a base level they fill a similar place to gambling in a players life, but i don’t also see them making efforts to gamify learning any coping strategies or other healthy practices, either. i dont think the games are evil for NOT doing that, but thats something i think any genre of game could be good at using systems/mechanics to teach players

Ah! I was speaking more to people’s moderate desire to gamble, aka I feel like literally everyone I know buys lottery tickets several times a year for some reason. Full-on addiction recovery is a whole other thing that’s best left to medical professionals, not game designers. Though it’d be cool to see what could be done if the two professions intentionally collaborated with recovery treatment in mind!

On a similar topic, I feel like there’s actually been a rise in mental health oriented games, like game developers are trying to pass on the knowledge and coping mechanisms they’re learned in therapy or just through life experience, and/or shining a light on their personal experiences so that others feel less alone. Which I love to see! My dad likes to gripe that when he was in school they didn’t teach you about emotional intelligence, so I’m happy to see a bit more nuance and grace around emotion in (SOME) games these days.

Yeah, but to drill down a bit: I don’t necessarily think manufacturing frustration is intrinsically bad. Manufacturing frustration is a way of adding friction, which creates meaningful choices and actions that accentuate the fun.

I think the key difference, then, is that the frustration here can’t be mitigated in any meaningful or compelling way. (This is also why I think Blue Prince is a pretty poorly designed game and I continue to be irked by the dismissal of this issue.) If I’m playing a game like, say, Spelunky or Caves of Qud, to pick some classics, these games have procedural generation and you can certain random items that give you a huge boost. But not finding such an item doesn’t ruin your run, nor does it feel like you’re just crossing your fingers for it. Even if I want a certain thing to drop, in normal play, its absence is mitigated by being able to use all these other things at my disposal, and often times, not being able to get the thing you want creates novel and interesting interactions. On the flipside, there’s games like Hades which, while I’m very cynical of how that style of Roguelite has overtook the scene, the randomization is almost never a threat to the success of your run.

Meanwhile, in a Survivors-like, the frustration is basically the only option other than a lucky roll. It’s not only that you can’t get what you want, but when you don’t get what you want, there’s kind of nothing interesting that can happen after that. All that’s left to do is to see if you can eke out a victory or lose. Further, this frustration exists, as you said, to drive engagement, and more specifically increase play time, more than it does to create a richer and more compelling experience. It just forces you to play another run.

The reality is though is that players want these things a lot of the time because they feel gratifying in the moment. They’re mindless and stimulating. And again, that can be okay from time to time, but I don’t think it is a fundamentally worthwhile design goal or paradigm.

To the other point, the comparison I’m drawn to is diet soda. (Well, first it was vaping, but vaping is even more questionable now…) Sure, it’s probably not as bad for you to drink Coke Zero than a classic Coke. But when we’re talking about what to produce, what we want to make, what we think would be good to make, I think you probably wouldn’t end up with Coke Zero. And if we’re asking what is good to design, it’s unlikely we’d pick a game with minimal input from the player and virtual slot machines that often sucks hours away from people’s free time.

This also reminds me of how I see the entire ARPG subgenre that we used to call Diablo clones, and it’s something that I rarely see people remark on. Diablo is a dungeon crawler; Diablo II is a loot clicker.

The original Diablo isn’t about loot or character-building, it’s about the crawl. It’s slower-paced than its descendants and is dripping with atmosphere. Magic items are straightforward and somewhat uncommon. There are no skill trees, just spellbooks and stat points. In single-player mode, the dungeon doesn’t respawn, and you have effectively unlimited storage space (even the NG+ difficulties weren’t available in single player until Hellfire). When you start a new game, your goal isn’t to theorycraft the ultimate rogue with all the best-in-slot gear; it’s to beat the game by killing Diablo. Everything you find in the dungeon is a means to that end. You aren’t going to find everything you want, but part of the challenge is to make do with what you can get, and it feels great when you do find (or even buy) something that gives you a major boost. Even in multiplayer, which is more of a long-term grind by its nature, loot and character progression are basic enough that it doesn’t just feel like a numbers game.

Reviewers often use the word “addictive” as praise, and they definitely did for Diablo. I played a LOT of Diablo back then, but its addictive qualities don’t feel manipulative, malicious, or even deliberately engineered. You keep playing because it’s fun and because it’s just randomized enough to feel fresh with multiple playthroughs. Finding cool items is part of the fun, but it isn’t the whole point. The game is the point, and it actually still holds up pretty well today.

Diablo II introduced sockets, rune words, set items, legendaries, gambling, the Horadric cube, and a bunch of other nonsense (not all directly related to itemization) that degraded the gameplay and the design focus into an obsessive min-maxing loot hunt. Loot drops like rain and just dealing with it all is a major component of the game. This is the path that pretty much all of its descendants have taken. Look up reviews for any loot clicker and see how many of them enthusiastically use words like “explode”, “fountain”, “geyser”, or “firehose.”

I don’t like these games. On the rare occasion that I do play one, I inevitably quit because it buries me under a tidal wave of garbage. I can appreciate wanting to create deeper and more complex mechanics to an extent, but I feel like the whole genre has shifted towards primarily focusing on and catering to meta play (the underappreciated Shadows: Awakening is one of the few exceptions). I can only assume that this is meant to amp up addictiveness and encourage long-term engagement. Apparently it works, but certainly not on me.